I Was Wrong About What They’ll Remember

Everyone feels like blue at some point.

Early in my teaching career, I hated the saying, “They might not remember what you said, but they’ll always remember how you made them feel.” I didn’t like it because the goal of a teacher is to cause learning. I thought, “If they didn’t remember what you taught, then you didn’t achieve your goal – so what does it matter how they felt?”

I was naïve.

As I shared in the second issue of Gathering Points, “memory is the residue of thought,” (from Dr. Daniel Willingham, Professor of Psychology at UVA and the author of “Why Don’t Students Like School?”). In truth, my students thought far less about geometry proofs than about whether they felt comfortable, safe, and welcome in my classroom and in the school overall. So that’s what’s in their memory.

Think back to times when you’ve felt uncomfortable at an in-person gathering, even as an adult.

For me, it’s event receptions or cocktail hours where I don’t know anyone. I remember the feelings of “Do I belong here? Where should I stand? Who wants to talk to me? When can I leave?” far more than I recall any specific details of most conversations I eventually had. My memory is mostly feeling that I didn’t belong.

And the sense of belonging any of us feel at a meeting or in-person gathering impacts how well we show up and engage.

When we don’t feel like we belong, it causes stress, since we perceive some kind of threat.

The “fake it ‘til you make it” mindset is a stress coping mechanism: act like you belong to reduce your perception of threat. When under this stress, our brains only perceive and focus on what we believe is relevant to the threat.

Think about the trope of a “new kid” at school walking into the cafeteria for lunch and not knowing where to sit because they don’t know where they belong. The same basic brain mechanisms are often involved in routine weekly gatherings with lower stakes.

Whenever someone walks into a room feeling like they don’t belong, everyone else in the room has a choice to make.

That discomfort presents an opportunity to create moments that turn “Do I belong here?” into “I feel welcome already.”

So how can event leaders, educators, and facilitators of in-person gatherings reduce stress and perceived threats to help everyone’s brains deliver the best critical, creative, and collaborative thinking?

  1. Eliminate barriers to engagement. In past issues we’ve identified several ways to make all gatherings accessible to everyone by default with respect to visual, audio, language, and mobility needs. Other needs to accommodate are scheduling, family, and dietary needs. Don’t make these an after-thought because when needs are not met, it causes stress.
  2. Affirm people’s identities to cultivate belonging. If everyone in the room doesn’t feel like they belong, then whoever brought the room together needs to figure out why and address it. But it’s not enough to just make everyone feel welcome. Leaders must also take the next step to prevent anyone from acting against that goal. That might mean quietly addressing someone who isn’t accepting or respecting others with a direct conversation. And setting group norms early and reviewing them often drives shared understanding for any group in community.
  3. Intentionally create opportunities for connection. There’s a real relationship between a sense of belonging and sense of connection. At those cocktail hours I mentioned, I logically knew I belonged in the room, but without connections to others, I didn’t believe it. Here’s the design-thinking approach to use: design gatherings with the assumption that at least one person there barely feels like they belong and has zero connections. With that assumption, you’ll necessarily have to create activities and seating arrangements that intentionally connect people. If you’re not the gathering’s facilitator, and just a participant, actively find people who might feel lonely or look isolated and engage them. If you’re standing in a group of people talking, use the “Pac-Man” strategy and keep the circle open so it’s always easy for another person to easily walk up and join the conversation. It’s like an open door.

In the next issue…

We’ll look at how our identities inform our sense of belonging and lay the foundation for how we engage with others. When we’re all able to bring our full selves to community and work, and leaders cultivate that, we’ll take our gatherings to the next level.


Have a gathering that went surprisingly well — or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.

Get the next issue of Gathering Points.

Subscribe on LinkedIn