Bueller? TED Talks? Anyone? Anyone?

Bueller... isn't here.

The only time I think it’s OK to say “kids these days” with any degree of disappointment is when younger generations lack shared cultural knowledge that older generations take for granted. I’m not sure how many Gen Z-ers read Gathering Points each week, but as I typed out this week’s newsletter title, I wondered how many would get the reference (Note: My 21-year-old did not).

As every Gen X-er knows, it’s from the 1986 movie “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off.” Actor Ben Stein, seen in this week’s newsletter image (whom my 21-year-old DID recognize), plays an economics teacher with an iconically flat monotone as he takes attendance (“Bueller? Bueller?”) and lectures uninterested students about the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act. He blandly fires questions at his bored students, leaves no time for replies, and apathetically asks, “Anyone? Anyone?” before answering them himself and plowing ahead.

That scene was as “viral” as something could be in the days before social media, and it’s permeated U.S. culture for decades because (1) it was so relatable to everyone as a classroom experience, and (2) the movie came out at a time when there were far fewer movies and TV shows competing for our attention. It’s also a perfect example for this week’s focus on the first type of in-person gathering using a framework defined by its impact on attendees: Presenting.

In this type of gathering, attendees feel they are passive receivers. And that’s not necessarily a bad thing. As I shared last week in the introduction to this series, Presenting is also the first of four stages on the Transformation Journey, as leaders consider whether a presentation format will ensure the gathering achieves its goals. As a reminder, here are the four stages in a nutshell:

  1. Presenting – “They’re telling me the same stuff they tell everyone.”
  2. Inviting – “They stopped to ask me a question.”
  3. Engaging – “They care what I think.”
  4. Belonging – “They care how I feel.”

For Ferris Bueller’s economics classr, Presenting is woefully inadequate for achieving learning goals. And an important nuance is that simply asking questions doesn’t mean people are being invited into the gathering. Even though the teacher was asking the class questions, it was performative. The questions were merely a way to fill in the blanks of his own presentation. The Inviting stage is defined as, “They stopped to ask ME a question,” but Bueller’s teacher never asked a specific student anything.

The teacher certainly wasn’t trying to Engage students, since he didn’t seem to care what they thought.

Whoever is doing the thinking is doing the learning, and the teacher was the only one thinking in that scene.

And it’s safe to say none of his students thought they Belonged there or that their teacher cared how they felt.

While Bueller’s economics teacher needs to put his classroom practices on a Transformation Journey, some gatherings are perfectly fine at the Presenting stage because of their goals. Ceremonies, conference keynotes, religious sermons, book readings, and research lectures can meet participants’ expectations and achieve the gathering’s goals without stopping to ask specific attendees a question. The key is that attendees are satisfied being passive receivers because of the nature of the event.

TED Talks: Presenting Done Well

TED Talks have come close to perfecting the Presenting format while exceeding audience expectations. They’re limited to 18 minutes, have a single presenter, and follow a format many TED speakers use that makes it easy to pay attention: a hook, a big idea, a story, three main points, and minimal visuals. Attendees understand the value is hearing new ideas, not contributing their own. And the conversations and gatherings around the actual talks are what give TED conference participants a chance to engage and feel like they belong.

That’s an important insight about context. A single event spanning a few hours or days can include gatherings of different types. A keynote can be Presenting while the post-keynote sessions can be designed for Belonging.

When Is Presenting the Right Type for your Gathering?

When evaluating whether a presentation format is appropriate for a particular gathering, here are some simple “look fors” and considerations you can use to decide whether your gathering needs to move to the next stage of the Transformation Journey.

Presenting: Positive Things Attendees Might Say

  • “I appreciated everything that was shared.”
  • “That presentation was excellent.”
  • “I got exactly what I came for.”

Presenting: Negative Things Attendees Might Say

  • “They’re just telling us information that I’ve already read on the website.”
  • “This meeting could’ve been an email.”
  • “It was too much information and too boring – I zoned out a lot.”

Appropriate Gatherings for Presenting:

  • A TED Talk
  • A graduation, gala, or award ceremony
  • A conference keynote
  • A religious sermon

When Presenting Is Not Appropriate (and a Transformation Is Needed)

  • A prospective student’s guided campus tour
  • Parent-teacher conferences
  • A college financial planning introductory overview meeting for families of 11th graders
  • Daily classroom lessons (though research published in the foundational book “How People Learn” shows an organizing lecture can be powerful after students have grappled with an idea)

In the next issue…

Just in time for Thanksgiving, we’ll dig into the second type of in-person gathering, which is Stage 2 of the Transformation Journey: Inviting. We’ll look at examples of when that’s the right design to meet attendees’ expectations while also achieving the goals of the gathering.


Have a gathering that went surprisingly well — or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.

Get the next issue of Gathering Points.

Subscribe on LinkedIn