Part 1 of 3
Information Delivered is not Information Learned
We’ve all been there. You sit through an hour-long meeting, walk out, and realize you’ve already forgotten most of what was covered. It’s not because you weren’t paying attention or weren’t interested. It’s because you’re a human, and our brains just can’t remember a lot of information we receive passively all at once.
Of all the gatherings we attend – conferences, orientations, town halls, guided tours – the informational meeting is the one we encounter most often. It’s also the one most likely to generate a very specific, very relatable frustration:
This meeting could’ve been an email.
That frustration is real. And we’re not wrong. But worse than the annoyance is the missed opportunity. There’s enormous potential when people gather in person: opportunities for improving connections, culture, learning, and building relationships that are more difficult when we’re remote. So when a meeting feels like it could’ve been an email, it means that potential was wasted, not just time.
This common experience is the perfect place to start and show what Gathering Points is about. Instead of merely lamenting problems, we’ll also uncover their root causes and design something better. So over the next three issues, we’re going to call out three myths that turn in-person gatherings into missed opportunities. We’ll share solutions to combat these myths so that meetings aren’t ever “in person emails” again.
Myth #1: Meeting in person makes information stick better.
Here’s the assumption behind most informational meetings: if we deliver important information in person, people will absorb, understand, and remember it better than if we sent it in an email.
This assumption prioritizes the speaker’s actions over the listener’s experience. And it misunderstands how our brains actually work. While it’s true that memory can be improved when tied to a location, that’s less likely to be true with familiar locations. So if a meeting is always held in the same physical space, we can’t rely on the space itself to help the information stick better. We’ll discuss more about this reality in the next issue.
Dr. Daniel Willingham, Professor of Psychology at UVA and the author of “Why Don’t Students Like School?” wrote that “memory is the residue of thought.” Instead of relying on physical proximity, we’re far more likely to remember what we’ve actively spent time thinking about. When we receive information passively, such as sitting in a room while someone reads from slides for an hour, it goes in one ear and out the other. Being in the same room as the speaker doesn’t change that. Proximity doesn’t improve retention; active thinking does.
Here’s an example of how a meeting I recently attended activated thinking in a simple way to achieve a key goal. At a community meeting with the school district I live in, we had to discuss rising expenses outside of the district’s control. District leaders needed to ensure everyone understood how costs have risen dramatically for the district over the past ten years.
If they had handed out a list of cost changes over time, the information would have been easily forgotten. So instead, they invited tables to play a low-key team version of “The Price is Right,” with short quizzes on the costs of things like water, curriculum, and school buses. They told us that in 2016 the district water bill was around $375,000 to give us a starting point. Then our tables had time to discuss and guess what the bill was in 2021 and projected for 2026. For the record: $415,000 in 2021 and a projected $982,000 in 2026.
That simple act of estimating makes it far more likely our brains will remember the information.
Before planning any informational meeting, ask these two questions to help decide whether a meeting needs to happen in person:
- What would be lost if this meeting was canceled and the information was sent as an email instead? If the honest answer is “not much,” that tells you a lot.
- If the goal is for people to learn and understand this information, what’s the best evidence to confirm they’ve actually learned it? If the answer is “we covered it in the meeting,” that’s not evidence. That’s hope.
One important exception is when the information being shared carries emotional weight or personal significance. When news affects people’s lives, their community, and their sense of belonging, the primary goal of the gathering isn’t information delivery. Information is secondary to taking care of people. And nobody complains that a gathering like that should’ve been an email. Because it couldn’t have been. The presence itself is the point.
For everything else, if the goal is just presenting information, then a meeting probably isn’t necessary. But if your goal is building connections, strengthening culture, or deepening learning, then be sure the meeting design will actually generate these outcomes. If people aren’t thinking during the meeting, then they’re not learning the information. And if they’re not learning, then the meeting wasn’t worth the time.
In the next issue…
Myth #2: People pay more attention when a meeting is in person. The truth is more complicated, and more interesting, than you think.
Have a gathering that went surprisingly well or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.
Get the next issue of Gathering Points.
