Part 2: This Meeting Could’ve Been an Email

Part 2: The Meeting Reloaded

Part 2 of 3

Proximity Doesn’t Remove Distractions. Design Does.

When video conferencing took over our work lives, a familiar worry came with it: Are people really paying attention? For all we knew, someone could be browsing other tabs. And if their camera was off, they could be doing anything. Maybe they weren’t even in front of their computer.

These concerns weren’t unfounded. But they led to a conclusion that was:

Distractions and disengagement are far less likely when we meet in person.

But they aren’t. We just feel like they are because we can see each other.

Myth #2: People pay more attention at in-person meetings.

In-person gatherings come with their own set of distractions: rooms that are too hot or too cold, poor acoustics, tech issues at the worst possible moment, the friend you haven’t seen in months sitting two rows over, the phone still in your pocket, the thing happening outside the window, the conversation you had to pause because the meeting is starting and everyone is looking at you.

Whether it’s virtual or in person, every meeting has a distraction problem. What neither of them have, by default, is a solution. That’s because the solution was never about the meeting’s location. It was always about the meeting’s design.

What actually captures and holds human attention isn’t proximity. It’s novelty.

Distractions are caused when people focus on something other than the meeting. Our brains are wired to attend to things that are unexpected, surprising, and a little bit different from what we expect. Every experienced elementary school teacher knows this. But the same principle applies in a boardroom, a conference hall, or even a virtual meeting. Whether conscious or reflexive, every distraction is caused by something our brain wants to attend to more.

Practically, that means rethinking what a meeting looks like from the inside and designing it differently. Here are some ideas to get you started:

  1. Better Slides. Don’t use slides that are a wall of text. That text can be an email. Instead, use slides that have provocative questions and headlines that stimulate thinking and will give people a reason to listen to details and engage during the meeting.
  2. Curiosity-Driven. Structure the agenda to stimulate curiosity and problem solving rather than topics. That could mean creating a short quiz to bring focus or a game show like the example I gave in Part 1. Schedule time for participants to talk to the person next to them (more on that next week). Let the agenda be driven by questions worth answering instead of simply delivering information.
  3. Less Ordinary. Do something out of the ordinary. Every meeting, team, and organization is different, so “ordinary” will vary widely. But it could be a moment of genuine humor, rotating speakers, or music before, during, or after the meeting. None of these are gimmicks. They’re intentional “distractions” that drive attention TO the meeting by designing for how human attention actually functions rather than against it. Those are the meetings that make people say: “It was that meeting where we all found a knock-knock joke on our chair.”
  4. Adjust the Space. Designing for participation and attention extends beyond the agenda to the physical space itself. As I mentioned in last week’s issue, being in a familiar meeting space doesn’t help information stick better. In addition, familiar spaces increase the likelihood of distractions because anything out of the ordinary will draw people’s attention. So make things in your meeting out of the ordinary. If you’re able to, have meetings in different locations. But if you have to use the same meeting space most of the time, try a different arrangement of tables and chairs, have people sit somewhere different than where they usually do, or leave a small note or item on people’s chairs when they arrive. Anything to make the space feel different each time, no matter how small.

Remember that meetings don’t lose people because of the topics and agenda. They lose people because the meeting’s format doesn’t give human brains a reason to stay engaged.

Proximity got everyone into the room. Design determines whether they’re actually there.

In the next issue…

Myth #3: People ask more questions at in-person meetings. If you’ve ever asked “any questions?” and gotten crickets, we’ll share how to change that.


Have a gathering that went surprisingly well — or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.

Get the next issue of Gathering Points.

Subscribe on LinkedIn