She Read My Letter!

A tale of cover letters before there were LLM tools

“Your cover letter says you have new and innovative ideas. What are they?”

This question was a defining moment in my career. It was the first question I was asked in an interview over twenty years ago. I was applying for school and district administration positions, most of them assistant principal roles. To give you a sense of what transpired, here’s a quick “Two Truths and a Lie” of how things went:

  1. I spent hours crafting cover letters specific to each position and application.
  2. My cover letters were read closely by every principal and/or HR team.
  3. I was rejected by some of the best school districts in St. Louis.

Though it shocked me at the time, now that I have decades of experience under my belt, I’m no longer surprised that number two was the lie. Now that I’ve been on the hiring side for years, I always read cover letters closely myself. But back then, learning my letters went unread left me deflated. But I kept writing them anyway, because they were helpful for understanding the position, preparing for interviews, and perhaps someday getting noticed.

And eventually, one was.

When I was invited to interview for a district K-12 Math Coordinator position, my former (but then-future) manager, Kathy Blackmore, came right out of the gate and asked me the question I opened with: “Your cover letter says you have new and innovative ideas. What are they?”

She read my letter!!!

I could hardly contain my excitement. She had read my letter AND asked me about the first thing I had led with in that letter. I went all in on my answer. I shared many ideas about math curriculum, assessment, pedagogy, technology, and more. It felt amazing because she identified something that was core to my identity as an educator – innovation.

When I got home and told my wife I had laid it all out on the table, she worried it might have been risky to be so out-of-the-box. I hadn’t had many interviews, and ruining the one I got would have been bad. That honestly never occurred to me. And after a brief moment of doubt, I said something like,

“I was my authentic self in that interview. They asked a question I cared about, and I told them what I envisioned. If I’m not what they’re looking for, so be it. If I had pretended or held back, then they would have been interviewing and considering a different person than who I am. And then if I got the job, I’d have to keep pretending. And I wouldn’t belong. Being myself makes sure we all know what we’re getting.”

This is something Brené Brown said much more succinctly:

“True belonging doesn’t require you to change who you are; it requires you to be who you are.”

In the interview, I presented myself as an innovative leader in education more than a math teacher with innovative ideas. That’s how I still think of myself, and that identity is prominent whenever I step into a room.

Three Ways To Help Everyone Bring Their Full Selves

After a restful Labor Day holiday, Gathering Points is back this week with the third and final post for this series about maximizing impact of your meetings by creating the conditions where everyone can bring their full, best selves to any gathering.

If people in the gathering don’t feel like they belong or don’t feel safe, then it’s difficult for them to bring their best selves to the work. Everyone can work to improve meeting culture and gathering impact by celebrating that we all have multiple identities. Gatherings get stronger when we invite people to share how their identities impact how they engage and what matters to them in community, family, life, and work.

While an interview isn’t exactly the kind of gathering we’re focused on here, it’s an example that illustrates three ways to create this culture of celebrating identities.

1. Be curious – with discretion – by taking others’ leads

It will take a while for people to feel safe and welcome in a group or meeting. I had opened my cover letter with a claim that I had innovative ideas, but didn’t share specifics. So, Kathy rightly assumed that innovation was something I wanted to talk about, and she also needed to know whether what I meant by “innovative” aligned with her vision for the district and her team. That one informed question told me she’d actually read what I’d shared about myself, and it gave me permission to bring my full identity into the interview. I immediately felt like I belonged there.

Curiosity with discretion means we don’t just ask open-ended questions about someone’s identity, especially if it’s personal information in a professional setting. It means referencing what someone has already told you, whether personal or professional. People are intentional about when and what they share about their identities, and it’s not appropriate or welcoming to ask certain personal, probing questions. A classic bad example would be asking a married couple when they plan to have kids or asking a single person if they’re dating anyone. Those questions make assumptions that are not welcoming. Whether it’s a kickoff meeting for a new team or a longstanding gathering, be mindful of what they’ve shared and focus your curiosity on what they’ve disclosed.

2. Invite people to lead with what matters most, not just their role

People often introduce themselves by title, but the identity that matters most to them is often  something else entirely. When Kathy’s first question opened the door, my identity as an innovator came through first. I wasn’t thinking of myself as “a math teacher with a few ideas.” I’ve had creative ideas in every job I’ve had, trying to make things better and improve incrementally – busboy, dishwasher, RA, camp counselor, etc. So, I answered as an innovative leader in education, because that identity matters more to me than a job title.

Leaders and teammates can invite this same shift simply by asking what drives someone, not just what they do. Curiosity about what motivates someone professionally is a personal question that doesn’t infringe on personal information. That distinction is important because it doesn’t require people to share something that they’re not comfortable sharing in a professional setting.

3. Reward authenticity when it shows up

Inviting people to share their identity only works if honesty is met with genuine interest instead of hesitation or obligation. When I answered fully, even though my wife worried it was a risk, I felt that whatever happened next I’d be able to continue being my full self whether I got the job or not (I did get the job).

If we want people to keep bringing their full selves to our work and gatherings, that authenticity has to be welcomed and protected every time, not just tolerated once. Leaders set this tone not only by inviting people to share, but also by how they react to the first honest, unscripted thing someone shares.

In the next issue…

We’ve spent several weeks on belonging as the foundation. Next week we’ll finally get to what it makes possible. Once people feel like they belong, what next? We’ll look at how to make sure a gathering of people who feel welcome accomplishes what they came together for. Whether you’re facilitating a team of eight or an auditorium of eight hundred, the principles are the same.


Have a gathering that went surprisingly well — or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.

Get the next issue of Gathering Points.

Subscribe on LinkedIn