Decide Which Meetings Are for Decisions

Know why you're gathering

“Wait, we’re deciding now?!”

Most of us have been in a meeting where we – or others – were caught off guard because a key decision wasn’t clearly on the agenda, if at all. That’s not a good surprise. If the cause of unhappiness is unmet expectations, then unexpected decision points make for unhappy meetings.

Here’s a simple way to make your meetings and in-person gatherings better while also reducing the number of “Disagree and Commit” moments:

Make sure the group knows explicitly whether the purpose of your time together is Dialogue, Discussion, or Decision. Put it at the top of the agenda and in the calendar invite title.

Especially in business settings, there’s pressure to “make every meeting productive.” While I believe that’s true, people too often assume “productive” means “a decision is made.” But even when you have key people in the room, that doesn’t mean a decision can be made, needs to be made, or should be made. People need time to talk through things, make sense of ideas, and figure out what questions haven’t been asked.

That’s why setting the purpose of the meeting improves meeting satisfaction and happiness. Dialogue, Discussion, and Decision are three kinds of engagement for any gathering. There are several sources you can research if you’d like specific protocols and tools for using them in meetings, including David Bohm’s work on Dialogue and William Isaacs’ at MIT. If you’re familiar with the Divergent, Emergent, and Convergent framework from the book Gamestorming by Dave Gray, Sunni Brown, and James Macanufo, there are useful parallels.

Dialogue

With Dialogue, there’s no expected landing spot or decision from the conversation. Its root words mean “talking through” something. Time spent in Dialogue is dedicated to making sure everyone understands the context, has a chance to ask questions, dig deeper, and think through things out loud. The conversation is open and judgment free, so brainstorming would be considered Dialogue where divergent ideas are surfaced. Dialogue isn’t about reaching an answer, let alone any “right” answer.

Importantly, meetings focused on Dialogue aren’t just reserved for the first meeting of a project or decision-making process. I recommend having Dialogue sessions throughout any decision-making process as a means for gauging everyone’s understanding and comfort with decisions as well as providing time and space for incorporating new learning and insights. Most Town Hall meetings are structured for Dialogue because there’s no decision being made, and space is being created for everyone’s voice to be heard. But even when Decisions are about to be made, a Dialogue meeting in advance is valuable.

Discussion

Once the ideas and options from divergent, brainstorming Dialogue meetings are on the table, the next type of meeting purpose is Discussion. Its Latin root means “to shake apart,” and the goal here is to narrow down options and make progress toward a Decision. It’s simple to make this transparent by saying, “This meeting is for Discussion, so while we won’t reach a Decision during this meeting, we expect to reach a Decision very soon.”

Depending on the team’s needs, context, and timeline, that next meeting for Decision might have to be next month, or it could be tomorrow. I recommend that at least one day passes so people have a chance to sleep on it before a Decision meeting. Sleeping is a necessary and helpful function for reaching better decisions because information is consolidated and new ideas about what we thought during that day can surface. Check out RadioLab’s episode “Dreams” from 2010 to learn more about how sleep helps our thinking

Decision

Gatherings whose stated purpose is Decision are the ones most people are familiar with and the most common. Typically, school boards, public boards, and government entities will publish a meeting cadence that declares that there will be hearings for Dialogue, agenda items for Discussion, and then Decision meetings when key votes are being made. This transparency is healthy for any organization, because it means decision moments don’t come as a surprise to the people they affect.

That said, many group decisions are relatively low stakes and neither complex nor complicated, which means decisions can be reached in a single meeting. But for more complicated matters, better decisions will be made when ample meetings labeled as Dialogue and Discussion have taken place. Plus, people won’t be surprised when a meeting for Decision is scheduled. And with transparent meeting purposes, if anyone “Disagrees and Commits” along the way, everyone will be clear on where the disagreement is located. Or perhaps the plan would have already changed in light of disagreements surfaced addressed in Dialogue and Discussion meetings.

In the next issue…

In any group, conflict is inevitable in any type of meeting. Therefore, conflict resolution is essential. Last week’s issue was about locating strategic disagreement; next week will be about resolving conflict in a way that protects relationships. I’ll share a useful framework that also strengthens the gathering and team.


Have a gathering that went surprisingly well — or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.

Get the next issue of Gathering Points.

Subscribe on LinkedIn