Your Goals Aren’t a Strategy

Even if it's neither known nor named, everyone has a strategy.

Even when a team or group is welcoming and everyone feels like they belong, time spent together will be unproductive when there isn’t alignment on short- and long-term outcomes. Importantly, clarity around concrete goals and milestones doesn’t automatically create alignment.

After a meeting, hearing any of these three things is a clear sign your group isn’t aligned:

“That meeting was pointless – I don’t get why we’re doing this.”

“Seems like there’s a lot of disagreement on the team.”

“That was a waste of time because we didn’t reach any decisions.”

We’ll get into the first one in this issue, and the next two in future issues.

The Point: No One Knows the Strategy

Every gathering sits within the context of a larger organizational strategy. And in my experience, people often not only don’t know the overall strategy, but they also don’t even have a shared definition of what a “strategy” is.

I recommend Richard Rumelt’s book “Good Strategy, Bad Strategy” for any team or organization that wants to align people on key outcomes and build a plan to achieve them. To briefly summarize, Rumelt defines a strategy as having three key parts:

  1. A Diagnosis of the challenge to overcome
  2. Guiding Policies to overcome the challenge
  3. Coherent Actions that align with the guiding policies

Here’s an example of these three components using the story I shared in an earlier newsletter about how Head Coach Lionel Scaloni turned around Argentina’s men’s national soccer team:

  1. Diagnosis of the Challenge: Argentina has the best player in the world, Messi, and a talented roster. But the team hasn’t succeeded with him in international play because he doesn’t feel fully accepted as Argentine. Even major sportscasters say he’s more European than Argentine. That feeling that he doesn’t belong keeps Messi and the entire team from playing to their potential.
  2. Guiding Policy: Build a roster of players who believe Messi belongs. When the locker room affirms his Argentine identity instead of questioning it, they will truly become a team.
  3. Coherent Action: Recruit Argentine players who have spent years playing soccer internationally and understand what it means to love a homeland that no longer quite feels like home.

A Second Example, Currently in the News

Ten years ago, Nikole Hannah-Jones wrote a New York Times Magazine piece about choosing an elementary school for her daughter, Najya, in one of the most segregated school systems in the country. She revisits that decision in an interview in this week’s episode of This American Life titled “An Argument,” which includes conversations with Najya, who is now 16.

Here’s how I’d break Hannah-Jones’ strategy into these three components:

  1. Her Diagnosis: Schools in the United States remain deeply segregated, that segregation harms Black children, and that segregation is a choice. She specifically says this in the This American Life episode: “What we are doing to Black children is immoral. And that I have not wavered on, I will not waver on. I want us to understand that we choose this.”
  2. Her Guiding Policy: Integration is the most evidence-backed remedy for improving schools for Black children and all children. And integration requires that families with resources (like hers) stop opting out of their neighborhood public schools.
  3. Her Coherent Actions: (A) Enroll her own daughter in their under-resourced neighborhood school rather than a higher-performing one. (B) Bring this conversation to the national stage in the hopes of inspiring communities to recognize the inequity of segregated schools and take action. (C) Encourage other parents with means to make the same choice she did as she practices what she preaches.

In the interview, we learn that Najya doesn’t argue with her mother’s Diagnosis. She accepts it. Najya’s disagreement is with the specific Coherent Action that impacted her educational opportunities and trajectory. Meanwhile, Hannah-Jones is reckoning with the impact of her choices over the past ten years.

That’s why explicitly defining all three components of a strategy is essential. Most arguments that feel unresolvable are arguments where nobody has said which component of the strategy they’re actually fighting about.

What Isn’t a Strategy

Some examples of things that are not strategies or elements of strategies:

  1. “Sell $X this quarter.”
  2. “Grow by Y% this year.”
  3. “Go win.”
  4. “Improve achievement.”

These are statements of hope, goals, or short- and long-term outcomes. They are not statements of a strategic plan. But they are alarmingly common in many organizations today. They don’t diagnose the barriers to those goals or provide any reasoned framework for what’s needed to achieve them.

Your organization’s goals and short- and long-term outcomes are likely better defined than your strategy. So if everyone feels like they can bring their best selves to the work but your team isn’t having the impact you want, it’s likely you don’t have a strategy with these three elements that ensure everyone understands and aligns on what the near- and long-term objectives are.

Defining and socializing these three elements is the first step to taking a team with shared belonging to the next level. It also lays the foundation for what comes next.

In the next issue…

“Disagree and commit” is a common phrase in the modern workplace. It’s also one of the least useful, because almost nobody aligns on the scope and stakes of the disagreement.

Najya and her mother agreed on the Diagnosis completely. Their disagreement lived at the level of Coherent Action. That distinction is the difference between productive alignment and demotivating frustration.

Next week we’ll look at how to navigate conflict and disagreement in your gatherings by naming where the disagreement is happening. Then the following week, we’ll get into the purpose and expectations of what’s happening in the moment at any given meeting.


Have a gathering that went surprisingly well — or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.

Get the next issue of Gathering Points.

Subscribe on LinkedIn