How Scaloni Turned Messi (and Argentina) Around

They couldn't repeat their 2022 World Cup win, but there's much to be learned from Argentina

Even if you’re not a soccer (aka football) fan, everyone who facilitates in-person gatherings needs to understand the reason for Argentina’s men’s team reaching back-to-back World Cup finals, winning in 2022 and falling just short this year. Even if you know the story of Lionel Messi and Argentina, you might not know one of the secrets behind their success.

Despite Argentina’s dominance over the past five years, their national men’s team didn’t win a single major international tournament between 2008 and 2021. That’s with Messi playing. In 2016, Messi even said he would quit the Argentina national team because he felt so awful he hadn’t delivered a win for his country. One of his most prominent media critics, sports journalist Flavio Azzaro, said publicly: “Messi is European. He’s an Argentinean who went to Europe and was raised in a society that is much calmer, where your money doesn’t lose value every day.”

In her five-part 2022 podcast series The Last Cup, host Jasmine Garsd uncovered what actually changed between 2016 and 2021. The whole series is insightful, moving, and worth a listen. And the final episode, “Team Añoranza,” names the shift that made all the difference.

The Real Diagnosis

Teachers, school leaders, coaches, and campus visit leaders already know that students need more than a warm welcome in classrooms, on teams, and on campus.

To truly learn, contribute, and achieve, people first need to feel like they belong.

Messi was born in Rosario, Argentina, and his family emigrated to Spain in 2000 when he was just 13 so he could join FC Barcelona’s youth soccer academy. In Barcelona, he had a sense of belonging. But with Argentina’s national team, something was different. Argentina was his home, but he didn’t feel fully accepted as one of its own. Garsd, who also emigrated from Argentina as a child around the same time as Messi, describes these feelings poignantly. Critics like Azzaro didn’t think Messi was Argentine enough. And a player who doesn’t feel accepted by his own home country can’t play to their full potential, no matter how talented they are.

A New Coach with a New Strategy

Lionel Scaloni, named Argentina’s head coach in 2018, understood that need for belonging in a way few others did. He’d grown up in Pujato, a rural town not far from Rosario, where Messi was born and raised. Like Messi, Scaloni had played professionally abroad in Spain and Italy. He knew what it felt like to love a home country you’d left.

Scaloni began leading an Argentine national team that – despite having arguably the greatest soccer player in history on their roster for over ten years – hadn’t won an international tournament in all that time. Scaloni’s diagnosis was simple, but not obvious:

The team’s and Messi’s underperformance was a belonging problem.

So Scaloni built a roster around solving it. He filled the team with players who shared that same experience as he and Messi: Argentines who’d spent years playing abroad and who understood exactly what it meant to love a homeland that no longer quite felt like home. None of them would ever make Messi feel like less of an Argentinian because they were all working through the same emotions.

For Messi, being surrounded by teammates who understood that feeling rather than players who doubted his belonging removed a weight he’d been carrying for over a decade.

Scaloni’s results speak for themselves. In the first four World Cups before Scaloni, Messi scored 6 goals total. In the two World Cups since, he’s scored 15, helping Argentina win the 2022 World Cup and reach the final again this year, which they lost 1-0. The more important outcome is that the culture Scaloni built outlasts any single result.

La Añoranza: The Longing to Belong

“La añoranza” roughly translates in English to “the longing.” And in that one specific way, Messi is no different than any of us:

We all carry a longing to belong.

Walk into a new job, a new classroom, or onto a new campus, and everything feels strange. Because it’s literally unfamiliar. Some people say “fake it ’til you make it” when you’re wrestling with imposter syndrome and don’t feel like you belong in the room or in your role. But that responsibility for cultivating belonging shouldn’t fall on the newcomer. It’s the job of the people leading the room.

Any leader can do what Scaloni did. Understand who’s in the room. Know what makes people feel like they belong.

Be aware of what quietly (or loudly) makes people feel like outsiders.

Then design your gatherings to close that gap as early as possible, before talent, effort, or good intentions ever get the chance to be undermined by the feeling of not belonging.

In recent issues of Gathering Points, we’ve explored how to make people feel like they belong at meetings and gatherings by providing default access for visual, audio, and language needs. In the next few issues, we’ll dig into the accommodation need every single person shares: belonging itself. You may be able to understand the language being spoken and see every slide clearly. Those things are necessary for a sense of belonging. But they’re not sufficient.

Like the Argentine national football team, the organizations that understand their communities well enough to design for real belonging will be the ones that push the bounds of what’s possible for success.

In the next issue…

We’ll look at the practical side of belonging. We’ll explore what it actually takes to make everyone feel like they belong in the room.


Have a gathering that went surprisingly well — or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.

Get the next issue of Gathering Points.

Subscribe on LinkedIn