Part 3 of 3
Everyone Has Questions. Most Meetings Aren’t Designed to Surface Them.
You know that moment in the meeting. The speaker stops, pauses, and says:
“Does anyone have any questions?”
Then… crickets.
Maybe one or two hands go up. But far more hands should be raised because people usually have at least one question that they don’t ask. So within twenty minutes of leaving, someone is sending a follow-up email with exactly the kind of question that should have been asked while everyone was still in the room.
This happens at nearly every in-person gathering. And the irony is that one of the most common reasons leaders choose to meet in person rather than send an email is specifically to create space for questions. Email is one-directional. If someone replies directly to the email with a question, the rest of the group never hears it or benefits from the answer. That’s a fair and legitimate reason to gather because others often have questions and ideas that don’t occur to everyone. But it overestimates what most people are willing to do when they’re sitting in a room full of other people.
Myth #3: People ask more questions at in-person meetings.
The silence after “any questions?” isn’t apathy. It’s the result of a long list of very human calculations happening simultaneously in every brain in the room:
I don’t want to look like I wasn’t paying attention. My question might be obvious. I don’t want to challenge the speaker publicly. I’m not sure how to phrase it yet. I don’t want to be the reason the meeting runs long. What if nobody else is wondering this and it’s just me?
Underneath all of it is perhaps the most powerful force in any room: social dynamics. People don’t ask questions in spaces where they don’t feel they fully belong, in front of people they want to impress, or in situations where asking carries any kind of social risk. The questions exist. They just never make it to the microphone.
This isn’t a personal failure. It’s a design failure.
And like the design failures we’ve covered in the first two parts of this series, it has a design solution.
Three approaches work consistently well.
- Structured Peer Conversation. Before opening the floor to questions, give people 2-3 minutes to turn to the person next to them and share something they’re wondering about. The room gets noisy fast. It’s basically cricket repellent. And when you ask for questions after they’ve talked with a neighbor, there will be plenty. That’s because people have already voiced their question to one person, refined it, and realized others have questions or are wondering the same thing. The social risk is gone. The question is ready. So try it the next time you get crickets. Instead of asking for questions again (Bueller? Bueller?…), say: “Take two minutes and share something you’re thinking or wondering about with the person next to you.” The room will come alive. It works every time.
- Digital Question Collection. The mobile devices people already have in their pocket can be used with software to enable people to submit questions throughout the meeting from their phones without ever raising their hand. This approach has multiple benefits: it can be made anonymous, people don’t have to feel like they’re interrupting or trying to wait for the right moment, and they can send questions the moment they think of them so they don’t forget. A college I work with used this approach during their new student orientation and received 72 questions from 60 attendees in an auditorium during an hour-long session. Of course they didn’t have enough time to address every question, but by collecting them digitally, there was a record of every question which could be answered in a follow-up. The meeting’s value extended beyond the room, and no question went unanswered.
- Solicit Questions Beforehand. Unless the gathering is because of a surprise or confidential announcement, it’s likely there’s an agenda telling people the topics to be covered. Even though people don’t have all of the details that will be shared in the meeting, people will have questions simply by having the agenda and basic background. These questions won’t be refined, but inviting people to share them in advance of the meeting achieves two goals. First, it gets people thinking before the gathering, which supports their engagement when they arrive in person. Second, it helps inform the agenda and what information is shared. Meeting planners often make assumptions about what prior knowledge people have about a topic, so by soliciting questions before the meeting, they can ensure the agenda and information presented are more relevant and complete for everyone.
Questions are proof that people were participating.
They weren’t just in the room; they were in the conversation. Questions are evidence that someone was thinking, following along, and engaged enough to want to know more. Designing for more questions to be asked isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s often one of the key reasons to gather in person.
The best designed meetings combine all three approaches: an invitation for questions beforehand, peer conversation during the meeting, and a digital channel to make sure no question goes unasked or unanswered.
Proximity gets people in the room. Design determines what happens when they’re there.
That’s the thread connecting all three parts of this series. Whether it’s retention, attention, or questions, the difference between a meeting that could’ve been an email and one that couldn’t comes down to design.
In the next issue…
We’re sharing our first interview for Gathering Points. We’ll move beyond just meetings and into the broader world of in-person gatherings as we learn with someone who’s spent nearly 20 years designing in-person college campus visit experiences, with a particular focus on what it looks like when every event is designed so no one gets left out.
Have a gathering that went surprisingly well — or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.
Get the next issue of Gathering Points.
