My elementary school principal, Chuck Hoppe, recently passed away at the age of 92. He was a wonderful principal, formative in my life from kindergarten through sixth grade.
At his memorial service, a former student shared remarks and described their first meeting, which, of course, was when he got in trouble and was sent to the principal’s office. Needless to say, Mr. Hoppe’s discipline and guidance were impactful because as an adult, they reconnected through church and became good friends and golf buddies.
I’m happy to say the time I spent with Mr. Hoppe wasn’t in his office for discipline. But hearing this tribute got me thinking about the first time one of my own kids made a bad choice at elementary school.
What he brought home from the principal was a “Make It Right Plan.”
I loved it.
My child had caused harm, and one part of his consequence was to specify exactly how he would go about repair.
I think that’s missing from teams and adult gatherings. Because conflict is inevitable in any type of meeting, conflict resolution is essential.
But too many conflicts get swept under the rug or ignored in the hopes that time will heal.
That’s the wrong strategy for repair and restoration and establishes an awful culture. It doesn’t define the challenge to overcome or specify the guiding policies that will inform the coherent actions to resolve it.
Teams need to resolve conflicts in a way that protects relationships, which requires transparency and intentionality. Here’s a simple four-step process I developed for resolution that’s centered on relationships and mirrors how the “Make It Right Plan” worked. And like last week, these four words all start with the letter D.
Disconnect
Recognize that the conflict has created a disconnect among at least two members of the team. Acknowledging this division is essential. Elementary school children need this step explicitly because they may not realize the impact of their actions and the harm they caused. And adults often don’t recognize it either. Microaggressions are a common example where a team member needs to understand how something they’ve said has caused harm.
Declaration
Let the people affected know the disconnect has been acknowledged and will be addressed. It’s important to match the declaration to the stakes and the scope. A quick private apology may be all that’s needed. But a conflict that affected the whole team needs the whole team to know that action is being taken. For elementary schools, the “Make It Right Plan” form serves as the declaration.
Declaring the disconnect also gives the team the opportunity to share their input on whether resolution is needed and what shape it may need to take. Failing to declare this acknowledgement undermines trust in leadership and the team. While some may be dissatisfied with the eventual resolution, trying to hide or ignore it will dissatisfy even more people.
Destination
Similar to how we set goals and plan backward from those goals, the team and those in conflict need to agree on what the resolution of the conflict looks like. My child’s destination was documented in the “Make It Right Plan,” which by its very title indicates there is a satisfactory repair to the harm.
I don’t remember my son’s exact infraction, but if it had been for intentionally making a mess in the cafeteria, then repairing that harm would include cleaning it up at a bare minimum. Going further, requiring him to help prevent future messes or clean up after others could be appropriate.
For other gatherings with adults and where the harm and repair aren’t necessarily clear cut, it’s even more important to document what the end result will be once the conflict is resolved.
Direction
Just as important as the end destination is aligning on the first step on the path to conflict resolution. In some cases, it may be easier to describe how things look at the end of this resolution journey than it is to figure out how to start the process of repair.
But just like planning a road trip, if we know where we want to go, we have to decide which way to drive and what the first milestone will be. The journey may not be clear yet, but you truly have to start somewhere. Be intentional and specific about that starting direction.
In summary: Name the Disconnect, make a Declaration acknowledging it will be addressed, align on a Destination for resolution in the best interest of relationships and the team, and choose a Direction to begin the process of repair.
Lastly, whenever Election Day is coming up like it is now, I recall that Mr. Hoppe would always tell us, seemingly at every assembly for the seven years he was my principal, this: “As soon as you turn 18, get registered and vote.” He’d tell us how close JFK won the Presidential election in 1960 and remind us that’s why every vote counts.
Elections are key Gathering Points in a democracy, so be sure you have a plan to vote in the November 3 election.
In the next issue…
A Make It Right Plan works partly because it’s written down and visible for personal and collective memory. Next week, we’ll look at why Documentation is the in-person gathering’s best friend, and how a simple record of what was said and decided can prevent the next disconnect before it starts (and not because documentation starts with the letter D, too).
Have a gathering that went surprisingly well — or one that taught you something the hard way? We’re always looking for stories and voices to feature in Gathering Points. Reach out any time.
Get the next issue of Gathering Points.
